Skip to content
Background Checks Jan 19, 2021

Are Background Checks Ever Not Consumer Reports?

Are background checks ever not considered a consumer report? Yes, if created in connection with an investigation into suspected misconduct...

Are background checks ever not considered a consumer report? Yes, if created in connection with an investigation into suspected misconduct relating to employment.

In the case Mattiaccio v. DHA Group, Inc., the plaintiff asserted three counts against the employer relating to the Fair Credit Reporting Act. A recent opinion in the case brought up a rarely discussed type of background check – one that’s not considered a consumer report and therefore not subject to the regulations of the FCRA. The exception for this type of background check is that the motivation must be borne from a misconduct investigation.

The defendants in this case argued that the background check in question, which occurred post hire, was initiated because of an investigation into the employee’s alleged misconduct surrounding the fact he was “far less than candid” in disclosing his background to his employer. The plaintiff argued the background check was performed in retaliation of a complaint he had lodged.

In this particular case, the court did not grant summary judgment for the defendant, deciding that the “genuine motivation” for the background check was not clear. 

However, this argument is relevant to any employer who finds itself on the receiving end of an FCRA lawsuit wherein the circumstances for the background check were motivated by an internal investigation. This case validates that courts will consider the argument. 

Latest Articles

Is Your Front Desk a Security Vulnerability?
Chexpass

Is Your Front Desk a Security Vulnerability?

Is your front desk a security risk? Discover how modern solutions like Chexpass can transform it into a secure, efficient, and welcoming en...

September 24, 2025

Bchex Partners with Charter Connect to Support Charter Schools
Partnership

Bchex Partners with Charter Connect to Support Charter Schools

Bchex partners with Charter Connect to enhance charter school safety and efficiency through advanced background screening and innovative en...

September 18, 2025

Leadership Lessons from Unexpected Places
leadership

Leadership Lessons from Unexpected Places

Discover unexpected leadership lessons from wolves, sitcoms, historical figures, and more to enhance adaptability, resilience, and creativi...

September 12, 2025